Your home’s exterior plays a critical role in its value. Curb appeal ranks in the top eight factors that affect how much your home is worth. A well-maintained and clean home makes a great first impression on those who see your house, whether or not you’re planning on selling anytime soon.

Many homes have vinyl siding on them. If your home’s exterior is starting to look faded and worn, you might be considering vinyl siding replacement or painting. Some people think that painting it might be a cost-effective and quick solution to making their house look more attractive.

There are pros and cons to painting vinyl siding. This guide will discuss everything you need to know about painting vinyl siding and why vinyl siding replacement is the better option.

Can I Paint My Vinyl Siding?

You can paint vinyl siding; however, you need to pick the right paint for the siding. Acrylic latex paint and thoroughly cleaning the siding beforehand will ensure your paint job looks seamless and flawless.

What Are the Pros of Painting Vinyl Siding?

There are a few benefits of painting vinyl siding. Let’s discuss some of the most common ones.


A fresh paint job will make your home look more aesthetically pleasing. Paint can also hide any imperfections that might’ve appeared on your siding since its installation. You can also transform the look and feel of your home by changing the color.

Cost Effective

Painting your vinyl siding yourself can save you more money than if you hired a professional. It’s also cheaper than replacing the siding.

Increase the Value

Painting your house can increase its value. A faded paint job can hurt your home’s value, especially if you’re getting ready to sell your home or get appraised for refinancing purposes.

What Are the Cons of Painting Vinyl Siding?

Painting your vinyl siding might seem like a more appealing option than replacing it; however, there are more disadvantages to painting siding than there are advantages.

You Might Void the Warranty

Some vinyl siding companies won’t honor the warranty if the siding has been painted. This includes brand-new siding. You’ll have to check your warranty information to evaluate if painting it will void the warranty.

Another thing to keep in mind is if your home gets damaged and you have to file an insurance claim. Your home insurance company might not honor your claim if you’ve painted your vinyl siding.

Painting Equipment Is Expensive

Painting your home’s interior rooms is generally a DIY project that the average homeowner can undertake. You don’t need a lot of fancy equipment to achieve a professional-looking paint job.

On the flip side, painting your home’s EXTERIOR is far more complicated. You’ll likely need high-end tools and equipment, such as:

  • Ladders
  • Scaffolding
  • Paint sprayers
  • Compressors

You’ll also have to prep your home and outside space. If there are errors in your paint job, they’ll be something for the entire neighborhood to see.

Painting Is Time-Consuming

While you might save money at the outset when choosing to paint your siding, it’ll cost you more in maintenance and time. Depending on how large your house is, it could take you days, sometimes weeks to paint the house. Staying on top of the paint maintenance will also suck time out of your day.

Vinyl siding replacement might be a more significant investment, but partnering with a reputable vinyl siding contractor ensures that you get the job done right. You’ll also be covered by a warranty for any repairs or damages that might incur. A professional company will handle those repairs, leaving you with time to do other things.

It Negatively Affects Your Siding’s Integrity

Your home’s vinyl siding is its first line of defense against the elements. Many people might think that by painting it you’re increasing the protection for siding, but that’s not the case.

When you have your vinyl siding replaced, your old siding is removed. Vinyl siding experts will evaluate your home. They’ll look for damage from:

  • Walls settling
  • Pests
  • Moisture

They’ll correct those issues before the new siding gets installed. You won’t know about any underlying problems if you paint your siding. Damage caused by rocks, hail, or wind won’t get fixed if you paint over the problem.

Locating damaged spots in your siding is crucial. Pests and moisture can infiltrate your home through these weak areas. You might have more serious problems to worry about than dingy vinyl siding.

Why You Should Replace Your Vinyl Siding

Replacing your old and outdated vinyl siding can significantly impact your home’s appearance. There are more benefits to replacing the siding instead of painting it.

Recoup Your Cost

Replacing your siding is a significant investment. However, you can recoup up to 76.4% of your cost when you opt for vinyl siding replacement. The total cost of your project will be less over time than if you painted it.

For example, say your vinyl siding replacement job cost $14,518. You can earn back around $11,093 when it’s time to sell your home.

Less Maintenance

High-quality vinyl siding shouldn’t need to get repainted. When the siding gets manufactured, it gets covered with premium paint. This paint is designed not to:

  • Bubble
  • Crack
  • Fade
  • Chip

The color will remain vibrant for the entire lifespan of your siding. The only maintenance you’ll need to do is clean it once a year. You can use a cloth with warm soapy water or a pressure washer.

Long-Term Solution

Installing new siding on your house is a long-term solution. New vinyl siding should last around 25 years, sometimes longer if you maintain it.

You can also make upgrades to your home when you have new siding installed. Improve your insulation and make your home energy-efficient.

Partner With Shield Home Exteriors for Vinyl Siding Replacement

Don’t waste your time and money painting your vinyl siding. Vinyl siding is designed to look good for many years. If you’ve noticed your home starting to look dingy or faded, it’s time to look into vinyl siding replacement with a siding contractor near you.

Shield Home Exteriors provides vinyl siding maintenance and replacement services to homeowners in Michigan. Get in touch with us to schedule a free vinyl siding consultation.